Tata Motors, once among the most-watched auto stocks in India, has seen its share price plunge around 45% in the last six months. From a 52-week high of INR 1,179.05, it declined to lows near INR 630–670 . Let’s break down the major reasons behind Why Tata Motors Share Is Falling, and what investors should watch for in the coming months.
1. Weak Performance at Jaguar Land Rover (JLR)
A primary driver of Tata Motors’ stock fall is the sluggish performance and lowered margins at its UK-based subsidiary, Jaguar Land Rover (JLR):
- In June 2025, JLR warned of flat cash flows and FY26 operating margins of just 5–7%, way below the earlier 10% target . Investors reacted swiftly, pushing Tata Motors shares down ~5% .
- JLR further flagged weak demand in China, Europe, and the UK, amplified by rising manufacture and warranty costs.
- U.S. auto tariffs added more pressure. The U.S imposes a 25% duty on foreign-made cars, which has notably dented JLR’s margins. A new U.S.–UK trade deal offers some relief by capping duties at 10% for 100,000 cars annually—but uncertainty remains .
These developments have undermined investor confidence in JLR’s profitability, dragging down Tata Motors’ valuations.
2. Downturn in Domestic Commercial Vehicles (CV)
Tata Motors commands around 38% of India’s commercial vehicle market, but faces significant challenges:
- Q2 FY25 saw 19.6% YoY drop in CV wholesale volumes, leading to 13.9% YoY revenue decline; H1 FY25 saw a 5.2% revenue dip.
- Reasons include disruptions in infrastructure projects, subdued mining activity, monsoon effects, and reduced fleet utilization.
- CV sales further declined by ~3–4% YoY in early 2025 .
Since CV contributes significantly to Tata Motors’ consolidated earnings, sustained slowdown hurts margins and stock sentiment.
3. Sluggish Passenger Vehicle & EV Sales
Despite leading in India’s electric vehicle (EV) space, Tata Motors is facing headwinds in passenger vehicle (PV) sales and this is a major reason behind Why Tata Motors Share Is Falling:
- PV volumes dropped ~4–5% YoY in Q3 FY25 .
- Issues with launching the Curvv EV delayed its ramp-up, affecting EV momentum .
- Intense price discounts (2–3 lakh on ICE cars, 3 lakh on EVs like Nexon) indicate weakening demand and rising inventory .
Price cuts, while boosting short-term sales, erode profitability and signal caution, unsettling investors.
4. Rising Competition — From India & Abroad is reason for Why Tata Motors Share Is Falling
Tata Motors is facing competitive pressure on two fronts:
- In India: Maruti Suzuki, Hyundai, and Mahindra & Mahindra have captured share in mass-market and SUV segments . EV challengers like MG, BYD, and soon Tesla, are threatening its dominant position .
- Globally: JLR is losing share in Europe and China, pressured by tightening consumer sentiment and rising discounts.
Reddit users echo this sentiment:
“Tata EV sales are on a downward spiral… Tata only has Sierra ev in the pipeline… reliability is a big question mark”
“Tata Motors vs Industry Average – slow CV sales… JLR’s struggles…”
5. Analyst Downgrades & Valuation Cuts
Key brokerages have re-rated Tata Motors:
| Brokerage | Action Taken |
|---|---|
| CLSA | Downgraded from “High Conviction Outperform” to “Outperform”; target cut from 930 to 765 (18% lower) |
| Jefferies | Downgraded to “Underperform”; target cut to 660 citing weak JLR demand & margin risks |
| Nuvama | Advised “Reduce”; highlighted miss on Q3 EBITDA and lowered FY25–27 EBITDA estimates |
These negative re-ratings have further chipped away investor confidence.
6. Macro & Geopolitical Factors
- The Israel–Iran conflict and rising crude prices have pressured Indian auto stocks, though Tata Motors was hit more due to heightened global uncertainties.
- U.S.–China trade tensions, EV subsidy changes, and supply shocks have added to the uncertainty .
7. Broader Auto Sector Slowdown
Tata Motors’ decline is part of a wider auto slowdown:
- The Nifty Auto index dropped almost 18% in recent months.
- Dealers across brands are facing high inventory—in some cases 80–85 days’ worth.
- Lower consumer sentiment and economic uncertainty are impacting vehicle sales across the board.
8. Company-Specific Structural Issues
Vintage/routine issues at Tata Motors have aggravated the decline:
- Corporate restructuring (TATAMTRDVR conversion) sparked share dilution and technical selling pressure.
- Quality and after-sales concerns are being frequently cited publicly .
- Weak pricing power, especially in PV and CV segments, limits Tata’s ability to maintain margins.
Consolidated View: What’s Dragging the Stock?
Combining all factors, here are the core headwinds:
- JLR’s weakening margins, cash flows, and higher tariffs
- Domestic CV and PV volume decline, compounded by heavy discounts
- Intensifying competition in passenger and EV segments
- Analyst downgrades and lower valuations
- Macro uncertainties and sluggish auto sector dynamics
- Structural and sentiment issues within Tata Motors
Is There a Silver Lining?
Despite the sharp fall, several positives could offer investors hope:
- CLSA suggests the worst may be priced in, with JLR trading at extremely low EV/EBITDA multiples .
- Q4 FY25 saw record consolidated revenue, net profit (28,100 Cr), and automotive free cash flow (19,400 Cr).
- An upcoming launch of the Electric Range Rover and new EV variants in India could revive consumer interest .
- CV cycle recovery is expected around FY26–27, which may support earnings .
What to Watch Next
Upcoming Catalysts:
- JLR FY26 margin update – any improvement vs the 5–7% forecast could boost sentiment.
- U.S.–UK trade clarity – extension of favorable tariff deals will help JLR.
- Indian auto sales volumes – recovery in CV, stabilized PV/Ev growth.
- New product launches – Curvv EV ramp-up, Range Rover EV debut, new domestic models.
Key Risks:
- Continued weak global demand and stubborn tariffs.
- Further margin cuts at JLR or weak free cash flow.
- Disappointing auto sales trends domestically.
- Corporate governance or quality-related setbacks.
Final Take: Is It a Value Trap or Opportunity?
Tata Motors looks like a deeply beaten-down stock:
- Down ~45% from its peak
- Margin of safety if JLR stabilizes and domestic segments recover
- But it also carries real execution & macro risks, leaving the stock vulnerable
As echoed on Reddit:
“It’s not a value buy, but a value trap.” reddit.com+7reddit.com+7reddit.com+7
For value-focused investors, Tata Motors may be worth watching—though patience and risk management are essential.
Summary Table: Key Factors Behind the Fall
| Factor | Impact on Stock |
|---|---|
| JLR margin cuts, weak demand, tariffs | High |
| India CV slump | High |
| PV & EV sales slowdown | Medium–High |
| Price discounts & thin margins | Medium |
| Analyst downgrades | Medium |
| Global macro & trade risks | Medium |
| Internal structural issues | Medium |
Final Thoughts
Tata Motors is navigating a pivotal moment—balancing global headwinds at JLR, domestic sales pressure, and competitive disruption. The coming quarters will be decisive. Investors should monitor JLR’s profitability updates, Tata Motors’ next-gen product rollouts, and macro indicators closely. A turnaround is possible, but not a certainty. For those bullish on long-term trends and willing to ride volatility, this could be an opportunity—if fundamentals deliver.
One thought on “Why Tata Motors Share Is Falling: A Deep Dive into the Slide”